Join the best football forum online!

Rate Your Player is the best football forum online. So why not join, create and debate with thousands of fans today!

Login   Sign Up Now


Man Utd Forum   ·   13 comments

Which Man Utd players should be shown the door and why?


Everyone has a different opinion on which Man Utd players should be axed. One person thinks a certain player should leave and another person thinks he should stay. In your opinion who should stay and who should go? Here are some players i think should go Rafael,Rio,Smalling,Young,Cleverley. I did not mention players we already know are leaving. So who should leave and why?


Added by member

crackentone by Crackentone (SEMI PRO)
Best Crypto Dividends Banner

Genius · Man Utd fan

Oh and Hernandez. God there's some many choices!..

  ·     ·     ·   5 years

Genius · Man Utd fan

Ferdinand can stay for one more year for all I care. Unless we go for someone like Mangala.

  ·     ·     ·   5 years

Genius · Man Utd fan

How someone can say Evra AND Buttner I don't know. We're only buying ONE left back this summer!
OUT: Evra, Cleverly, Nani (RVP if we buy striker)
IN: Shaw, Coleman, Herra or Fabregas or Kross (and REUS please)

Up top with this striker situation its plain the see, if Van Gaal comes in Van Persie stays, if Klopp comes in Reus comes. I'd rather the latter. Could even get Gundogan as well. Carrick's not getting any younger.

  ·     ·     ·   5 years

machine44 · Hull City fan

Evra, Evans, RVP, Cleverly, Young, Jones and Buttner.............. il get crucified for the RVP comment but his attitude been awful

  ·     ·     ·   5 years

jamesplutd · Man Utd fan

We know Vidic is going, but in still annoyed that we aren't getting any money for him. For that reason I would try to give players like Evra and Ferdinand 1 year contracts and then sell them, though I don't think the players would like that idea. Buttner, Smalling, Cleverley, Young, and Anderson(though I think he's already said he's leaving) should all go as none of them are even close to the standard of a top 4 team, let alone a title winning one. I wouldn't be fussed if Lindegaard, Jones, Evans, Valencia, Nani, Rafael or Welbeck go but we have to be getting a good price for them, and we will need replacements for them, but obviously they can't all leave or we won't be left with enough players.

  ·     ·     ·   5 years

AFC_Harry34 · Arsenal fan

Buttner, Evans, Ferdinand, Nani, Young, Cleverley, Hernandez

  ·     ·     ·   5 years

Doozers20 · Man Utd fan   In reply

@jimbo1984 like I said I've been critical of him this season but watching them live I could see that the other United players were doing him no favours at all

  ·     ·     ·   5 years

jimbo1984 · Man Utd fan   In reply

@Doozers20 I remember him having 3 good games 3 seasons ago.. Other than that he's been average at best..
Is probably still rather have cleverly in the line up than Fellaini though

  ·     ·     ·   5 years

Doozers20 · Man Utd fan   In reply

@jimbo1984 I think Cleverley is harshly treated at times, he hasn't been great but I was at the derby on tuesday and every time he got on the ball, no one at all showed for him ever.

He plays well in a quick, passing game and with noone showing anywhere near him, he's going to look terrible. Not saying he's world class or anything, but he'd be a good squad player, think he'd be doing a lot better in teams like Everton, Arsenal or even Liverpool. Did well for United when they played that sort of game partnering Anderson in midfield.

  ·     ·     ·   5 years

jimbo1984 · Man Utd fan

Fellaini- because he's useless
Cleverly - always thought he would progress into a top midfielder but he seems to have have gone backwards - provided nothing going forward and his passing is average at best.
Nani, Anderson, young.. -- for obvious reasons
Rafael - the only player I think we should sacrifice that I actually like.. His work ethic is top notch, but he makes way too many costly mistakes and had become a liability.
Smalling and jones I would keep as they both have potential to improve, Evans has a bit of big game experience so he's a uselfull player to have,
I'd hazard a guess that giggsy, rio and Evra will all join vidic in saying goodbye in the Summer...
Gonna be some massive changes next season whatever happens

  ·     ·     ·   5 years

Doozers20 · Man Utd fan   In reply

@crackentone no confirmation from what I've heard, he's in the same boat as Rio, who you said we don't know is leaving...

  ·     ·     ·   5 years

crackentone · Man Utd fan

So Evra is not leaving then....

  ·     ·     ·   5 years

Doozers20 · Man Utd fan

We only know of one player that's leaving...

Those who I wouldn't be upset to see leave would be... Lindegaard, Buttner (though could be decent cover), Rio, Evra (though I wouldn't be upset to see him stay either alongside a good young left back), Young, Anderson, Nani, RVP (as good as he is, and only abroad). I'm unsure on Giggs.

  ·     ·     ·   5 years